HomeMy WebLinkAbout02-02-1999 Articles4c the Gazette, Cedar Rapids, Iowa Sat . Jan- 30, 1999
Police reviews
face discussion
City attorney tells
council: Don't treat
allegations as fact
By Lynn M. Tefft
Gazette Johnson county Bureau
IOWA CITY — The Police
Citizens Review Board needs to
be careful not to treat allega-
tions of misconduct against po-
lice officers as fact, the city
attorney told the City Council
on Friday.
"An accusation is not an in-
ference of guilt, culpability or
anything," City Attorney Elea-
nor Dilkes said.
Council members met with
Dilkes on Friday to prepare for
their meeting with review board
members on Feb. 11.
One issue up for discussion is
whether officers should be iden-
tified in the police chiefs re-
ports to the review board in a
way that allows review board
members to track them.
Dilkes said she is concerned
about how the information
could be used.
She cited a recent review
board decision that upheld Po-
lice Chief R.J. Winkelhake's rul-
ing that an officer had not used
profanity during a traffic stop.
However, the board's report
stated: "It should be noted that
this is the second incident with-
in a six -week period that an
allegation of the use of profanity
has been filed against the offi-
cer."
The previous allegation, also
refuted by the police chief and
the board, should not be used to
judge the officer in the subse-
quent complaint, Dilkes said.
Council member Mike O'Don-
nell said he saw no reason to
identity the officers. "Each com-
plaint is individual and investi-
gation is warranted," he said -
Such a tracking system could
harm officers who, by virtue of
the beats and shifts they work,
are likely to thaw more coil'
plaints, council member Dee
Vanderhoer said.
But Karen Kubby argued that
identification is necessary be-
cause one of the review board's
purposes is to track trends.
FOUR OF the five review
board members observed Fri-
day's meeting but did not partic-
ipate.
Board Chairwoman Leah Co-
hen said later that identifying
officers with a number system
does not bias the board.
Cohen also disagreed with
Dilkes' suggestion that tracking
information could be provided
separately from the police
chiefs reports.
"It doesn't do much good to
have it after the fact," she said.
THE COUNCIL agreed to give
people 90 days, rather than 60,
after an incident to file a com-
plaint with the board.
However, only some council
members agreed with Dilkes'
suggestion to allow the police
chief to investigate complaints
and file his reports with the
board in a "timely manner."
The chief currently has 30 days
and can ask for extensions.
"The accurateness of the in-
vestigation overrides the time
factor," council member Dean
Thornberry said.
Council member Dee Norton,
who favors a specific deadline,
replied, "If I thought time was
related to accuracy, I'd buy
that."
Council members also differed
over whether the review board
should see all complaints filed
against the police department.
or only those filed through the
board. People have the option of
filing a complaint without hav-
ing the board review the chiefs
decision.
City Manager Steve Atkins
said he and the assistant city
manager also handle informal
complaints against the depart-
ment and do not document
them.
Vanderhoef said the board
could be provided general data
about the other complaints, but
her colleague Connie Champion
said the board needs to see all
the complaints to fulfill its job.
"The (review board) is sup-
posed to ensure that police are
acting in a way citizens want
them to act," Champion said.
"How can they do that without
information?"
Thornberry said he doesn't
want the board to have an ad-
versarial relationship with the
police department.
Police Union President Dan
Dreckman, who observed Fri-
day's meeting, said officers have
felt it was adversarial and said
he was encouraged by Thornber-
ry's remarks.
Cohen said the relationship
isn't adversarial at all.
"We feel right now that the
board has been in existence a
year and a half and it's time to
change some things," she said.
"Everyone needs to negotiate to
make it acceptable to all."
Opinion
Iowa City Press -Citizen
Letters
Let board
do its job
1 agree with evervilime in
your editorial, "Council cull
heart out of Police Board:'
except the conclusion.
The Police Ciii/ens Rev ic��
Board has developed .aid ahidcd
by a set of standard operutin,,
procedures.
The Review Board ,md the
City Council are ,ChedulCd to
meet on Fch. I I hom ? to 7 p.m.
III the council Chamhcn: to dis-
cuss their disagreements over
some of the prcedures.
The council could have
ed until aler this nICCMI' to
decide which procedures to olli-
cially adopt.
Two council incmbei,.
myself and Connic Champion.
voted to deter It decision until
then.
The majority said that we
could return to the Revicw
Board procedures after the Fch.
I I meeting if warranted.
The need to truck trends was
one of the kev reasons Ibr the
creation of the Revicw Board.
The council majority's vote ro
change the procedures hwn-
strinis the ability of the Rey ic\o
Board to fulfill its Clutic,.
Don't get rid of the Police
Citizens Revieti Bo,trd.
Change the standard ohcra-
ing procedures ,o Ilya the
RcCiew Board can do the joh it
�cas intended to do.
Karen Kllbbv
Ioea City
Page 13A
Saturday,
January 30,
1999
Page 3A
OUU Thursday,
January 28,
Iowa City Press -Citizen 1999
Local lawyer
gets nominated
for 6th District
By Jeff Charis-Carlson
Thr Mese-CiliCen
A local commission of Iowa
district judges named an Iowa
City lawyer as one of two nom-
inces for6th Disuicijudge.
The 6th District Judicial
Nominating Commission inter-
viewed 23 applicants Tuesday.
After the com-
1OWa City mission mem-
hers voted,
only two candidates remained:
Douglas S. Russell and Robert
Teig.
Russell is a partner in the
Iowa City firm of Stein, Russell
and Pugh. Teig is an assistant
Icdcral uttornev in Cedar
Rapids.
The two names will INC sub-
mitted to Gov. Tom Vilsuck,
who will have 30 days to (IMLIC
between the nominees.
Whoccerthe 8'O%CInOI appoints
will succeed htda' • Van D.
Lintntcl, who wes ,lpponitad to
the lone Court of r\ppC,de-
.'I'In very honored to he
nominated;' I2us*ell said. ' I nt
cen hunomd to ha\i the oppor-
lunit to be con'idcrcd liar ,hi+
position, which I think is a very
important one
Russell graduated from the
Ullocuiry of Iowa School of
Law in 1978. After graduation,
he worked as an assistant
Johnson County attorney for 20
months. He went into private
practice. in 1980 as an associate
in the firm Leff, Hauperl and
Traw. In 1983, he became a
Partner in his present firm.
Russell also serves as the
attorney for the Police Citizens
Review Board.
A district judge is appointed
initially for a one-year term,
until the next general election. If
retained, the judge may stand
for retention every six years.
Since the present retention
system began in 1963, only four
Judges have not been retained.
" f'hose were for grave mis-
conduct:said William R. Eads,
chairman of the nominating
Conuni»ion.
The 6th District judge will
xene Benton. Iowa, Johnson,
Joncc, Linn and Tama counties.
The full-time position includes
an annual ;glary of S97,6(X.
G
M
0" go
cc
� a a o o>� oc�aVmcO•o ''o
O
'4; ti 7 �tl
6 A U Q
El�wI C awi ° °' v �v, �y F:
0, F Y O Ui W
Y wY°5° O>' _ OA U OmOr�m ..Y3
LA m y° A tw C' w y Occ
y m
lO gyro! A CA { N. ❑�75
F m> E .0 G m .a 00 Ci G y Y i+ m A ctl W%, N F x T
O w0 w .C, y Y .. O
G. d'Cy �E m o cam c03w0,a0
Q c."mm m'O en rv���"NUmd E=5 O.n dx >N
.b .b O U N H _.Oiw0 0 � •O o> 3 C 3
ti cOq 'i� 3 w m v $'G 0. V G m O w '� DtO. o 0.9
m 2 0D
Y Li Y w N d>°
G C .4 C C o A> G r4 O :Q N oOi 'O T O
:1
7 U o as r 0 3 0 ° DD A O m T°
O 0 mU AOYY Y i
d
O° O O 0
Obw0..nH1 CTC'0w myY ° ��6'Du m•pC mCmG td CA
WO._GpNmCC0 C—03 V00
. YO
WC 0YC'w0
wmOC w:O O.'CCM
0Cu0, gaO0Po°koC mm mmm7cO b
° OW
> m'O
T P.,-
0C
wi0d
—° 0. 3 A 3' m h0 c+ °a; '� 3 :". $ mT Y O w q mGG O w m
a
O C Y O 0..,C. q° m ❑ m❑ O Z m Y H m _T yd' .b m 6 A d .O C A
0— 0 C o C O O C G d dA m m y p... A m oA
'tJ 0.0.r7 v.nA wm 3A wYm7w uAU YmOY
> c w n g m Nf6 o a �b ��'o d w
d o V V
- S (D b °' d �'° 0 LL O.o o w 3 q 8
■� Ea o oAv�y Baa8�3�gjm�8o4
V R a�i .L-.
m to
.2. O m G°�w 0)to
db 4) m'0
0 3 oc.� Y � d �.5 a a °' .0
y 2 Y p U
O 'O > H d U °� `� b M M pwp .>S w0 yj "�. m T G.• .Oq Y
O� E� �H yG�m�w'�00. TY.�Aa�°Ow
O " m C Cyr �w c p g 0 8 0 d m$
C O O >i W O ^' ai 'i+.r a wU co° S C �6) m O V Y o 'ro`� y m 8 w> aCi > F
on O,O M
2 a U A d a- 1. 8'6D °.° �
ASSISTANT if-AS.ACI>�r, Eijirntt. 315-_284-s06; Q br Des 10iloille5 lieQl51fC
e0lice complaints Complaints
fairness doubted treatment
uestioned
By FRANK SANTIAGO
AND TOM ALEX
RIU;I II.11 fit �I'F VPItrII iev
Most people who file com-
plaints with the Des Moines
Police Department say their
gripes don't get fair treatment
and that police show a bias to-
ward fellow officers when de-
termining fault, State Ombuds-
man William Angrick said in a
study released Wednesday.
1n a report that stems from
the 1991 controversial arrest
and alleged beating of a mail,
Angrick said the findings are
based on a survey of 90 people
that showed 70 percent believe
police usually favor tine offic-
ers targeted in complaints.
Also. 67 percent said they
weren't satisfied with the de-
parturent's final decision after
investigation, and 61 percent
said they didn't like the way
the situation was handled.
The survey of crime victims,
suspects, witnesses and peo-
pie who called the department
for various reasons was done
for the ombudsman by a pri
vat firm.
"I was hoping for a much
q
POLICE
Continuedfrom Page LLI
lesser proportion of people who
were dissatisfied," Angrick said after
the report's release. "The results
show that the system can be im-
proved, or shotdd be improved. I'm
not sure I'm willing to ,jump to the
conclusion that there is actually bias
because people believe that. But it
does concern me that the dissatis-
faction is that high."
Cidef Skeptical
Des Moines Police Chief William
Moulder, who was out of town and
not available to comment, said he
was skeptical in a letter contained in
the 24-page report.
"This survey is an attempt to mea-
sure dissatisfaction. We can agree
that people who file complaints are
dissatisfied," he wrote.
Assistant Chief William McCarthy
said Wednesday: "We are the only
police department in Iowa subject to
this review. To say it is the result of
an incident that occurred so many
years ago is to stretch credulity."
Milton Arrest
The report is an outgrowth of the
arrest of Larry Milton, who claimed
that his head and face wounds were
caused by excessive force by three
arresting officers. Milton's com-
plaints brought race relations to the
fore because he is black and was ar-
rested by while officers.
Moulder said after a department
investigation into the arrest that the
force used by an officer was "prop-
er." A report by the ombudsman
concluded that Milton had grabbed
an officer's weapon, and a second
officer was juslified in hitting Milton
seven to eight times with a flashlight.
Angrick then began another inves-
tigation to look at the department's
handling of complaints.
''The new study concludes that the
THURSDAY j�R
JAN[,.tRr 2�8, 1999 M DM
Survey response
■ A survey for the state
ombudsman's office showed
dissatisfaction with handling of
complaints.
..Say pow ,Za
favoritism to.f
officers,, ,M...'
...are dissastisfied
with explanation of
final decision.
are u6 " "
how cotttp{
were han
say police don't
keep them informed
during investigation.
SOURCE: State ombudsman's office.
NL\Rt: \L\RTIIRELL(VIIIE RWISTCR
Police Department is doing a better
job, but improvements are needed in
reviewing complaints.
Recommendations
Angrick has recommended that
complaint investigations not move
up the chain of command in the de-
partment because, in part, "a super-
visor might be motivated to ensure
complaints are not sustained."
Rather, the results of an investiga-
tion, usually done. by the internal
Office of Professional Standards,
should go directly to the chief, he
said.
Angrick recommended that "all
pertinent" aflegations of police mis-
conduct be recorded "regardless of
whether the matter is formally in-
vestigated." He said police kept a
record of only a portion of the
complaints.
McCarthy said most people in Des
Moines believe their complaints will
be taken seriously and that there will
be corrective action.
Romelle 11, Slaughter, admaustra-
lor of the Iowa Commission on the
Status of African -Americans, said he
has not gotten a complaint about the
Police Department in the four years
he has been on the job.
THE
PRAIRIE
PROGRESSI
6y ��R RIGjyTS
aVR I.tBERT`Pro ,fcF
�-yE WILL MAINTgIf�
wE PR
VE February 1999
A NEWSLETTER FOR IOWAw DEMOCRATIC LEFT
Millennial Honor Roll for 1998
ay attention, friends, 1999 is as
good as over. This might be the
last Honor Roll of the 20th
century, and soon there will be no more
talk of building a bridge to the
next one.
The past year was less than
glorious forhog farmers, Friends of Bill,
and the people of Iraq, but '98 had its
moments of honor. Most notable were
some remarkable prairie union triumphs.
650 Titan Tire workers repre-
sented United Steelworkers Local 164
have been on strike in Des Moines
since May 1. The battle against CEO
Morry Taylor is a tough one, but the
workers have successfully resisted
management efforts to drive genera-
tional and racial wedges between the
strikers, and continue to maintain a
united front.
More than 600 workers repre-
sented by International Brotherhood of
Electrical Workers Local 1634 went
on strike against Rockwell Collins in
Coralville. Unions from across the
state joined the IBEW picket line,
spurring the workers to victory and a
contract free from concessions in
health care and benefits.
450 nurses joined United Food and
Commercial Workers in Sioux City.
700 workers joined a coalition of three
unions at Prairie Meadows. Nearly 120
Head Start teachers, counselors, and
social workers voted to join Service
Employees International Union in Linn,
Johnson, and four
other counties.
SEIU was also starred in the year's
most dramatic labor victory, not only in
Iowa but in the nation, when 1900
nurses and professional staff at
University of Iowa Hospitals and
Clinics gained representation by
voting for SEIU's Local 150. Leading
the PP Honor Roll are attorney Matt
Glasson and the hundreds of UIHC
staff who demanded accountability and
respect from one of Iowa's most
paternal institutions.
•irt•
In an election year, only Kay
Chapman, Minnette Doderer, Ed
Fallon, Mary Mascher, and Dick
Myers of the Iowa House of Represen-
tatives voted against an $85 million tax
cut that disproportionately favored
wealthier Iowans. Said Myers,
"There's more to being in the Legisla-
ture than supporting tax cuts." All five
were re-elected easily.
One of the physicians who deliv-
ered the McCaughey septuplets, Paula
Mahone testified at the Iowa legislature
against the so-called "partial birth"
abortion ban, raised money for an
African -American history museum in
Cedar Rapids, and participated in the
Economic Justice conference spon-
sored by the American Friends Service
Committee. In contrast, the
McCaugheys endorsed Jim Lightfoot
and did TV ads for an electric drill.
Quiet and cautious Iowa City
council member Dee Vanderhoef cast
the tie -breaking vote in favor of
allowing same -sex couples/domestic
partners to qualify for federal
housing aid.
In her tenth year on the city
council, Karen Kubby showed why
she's the longest -serving member since
John MacDonald. Frequently on the
short end of a 6-1 vote, "the socialist
pot -maker" maintained her commitment
to open government and fiscal fairness
by opposing a local -option sales tax
ballot, opposing a $12 million parking
ramp, opposing a plan that would have
made the landfill the most elevated spot
in Iowa City, and opposing Dean
Thomberry for Mayor pro tem. Kubby
also worked to imbue the "peninsula
project" with citizen input from start to
finish, and to give local developers
some opportunities for creativity along
with profitability.
When a district judge threw out
charges of "public indecent exposure"
against the Southern Comfort Free
Theater for the Performing Arts, Scott
County Sheriff Michael Bladel threw in
Honor Roll,
Continued on Page 6
THE PRAIRIE PROGRESSIVE • FEBRUARY 1999 • PAGE 1
Johnson County Legislators
Promote Regressive Taxes
Johnson County progressives face
a real dilemma in the upcoming
election on a regressive local
option sales tax. Liberals and
progressives support progressive
taxes, but also support maintaining the
quality of our local civic institutions
funded by the sales tax. How did we
get into this dilemma, which gives us
the choice of supporting the local
public library only at the cost of a tax
that raises the burden on those least
able to pay?
The short answer is that our
Democratic legislators from Johnson
County created this situation. In 1982
Terry Branstad was elected governor
and Democrats took over control of the
legislature. Since that time, whether in
the majority or in opposition, Demo-
crats from Johnson County have
cooperated with Governor Branstad in a
major restructuring of our tax code.
The burden of taxation has been shifted
away from corporations and investors,
and placed squarely on the backs of the
wage-eaming majority of Iowans. The
local option sales tax is only part of a
much broader re -structuring of our tax
code, which has been brought into
conformity with the principles of
Ronald Reagan.
Contrary to what many Johnson
County progressives believe, our
legislators have not reluctantly capitu-
lated to the Reaganite agenda on taxes,
but have been key players in putting it
into place. When I first moved to Iowa
City in 1977, I was amazed to hear our
legislators routinely defend the sales
tax, claiming that it was "not really
regressive" because food and prescrip-
tion drugs are exempt. When
challenged, they would concede that
the sales tax is in fact regressive, but
change the phrase to "not so bad".
From their point of view, the fairness of
the tax code was less important than
raising money for state government.
Local activists on the Johnson
County Democratic Central Committee
had an entirely different view in 1988,
and the county party played a key role
in defeating the first local option sales
tax referendum by actively campaigning
against it. (It will be interesting to see
what role the central committee plays
this spring.) But local party opinion
had little affect on the views of local
legislators, who had voted to make the
local sales tax an option precisely in
order to provide more funding for
municipal government.
There have been six key pieces of
legislation in the regressive restructur-
ing of Iowa's tax code. In the 1980s
Iowa's 3% sales tax was:
• first raised to 4%
• then raised to 5%
• a local option tax made it 6% in
many Iowa communities.
Then in the nineties, legislators
• cut the relatively progressive
income tax by 10%
• eliminated most of the burden of
the inheritance tax, which falls
largely on unearned income and
capital gains.
Finally, in 1998
• they added a local option tax for
schools, pushing the potential
sales tax rate to 7%—more than
double the 1982 rate.
On the spending side of the
budget, these regressive changes in tax
rates were accompanied by a shift in
funding toward economic develop-
ments grants to investors in the
eighties, and by an unprecedented
expansion of state prison system in
the nineties .
With a very few exceptions, our
Democratic legislative delegation from
Johnson County has provided solid
support for this regressive re -writing of
our tax code. The exceptions are worth
noting. Although the majority of our
local delegation voted for the local
option sales tax for schools in 1998,
both Dick Myers and Minnette Doderer
voted no. State Rep. Doderer sup-
ported the sales tax increases of the
1980s, but courageously broke ranks
with the Johnson County delegation
and stood entirely alone in opposing
recent income and inheritance tax cuts.
Some members of our delegation are
now suggesting that it is time for Rep.
Doderer to retire.
Last month, as President Clinton
launched 450 cruise missiles on Iraq
without so much as a courtesy call to
Congress or the U.N. Security Council,
progressive Democrats held rallies, not
to protest this unconstitutional and
cynical exercise of military power, but
to defend the President and "the
integrity of the constitution." As soon
as the impeachment trial is over,
Clinton will of course join with the very
people who are trying to remove him
from office, and partially privatize the
social security system.
The assault on the key values of
the New Deal/Great Society Democratic
party is not merely coming from the
White House, but from Democratic
elected officials at all levels of govern-
ment. In local as well as national
politics, it appears to be impossible to
be an active progressive Democratic
without being put in the position of
promoting an agenda that undercuts
liberal and progressive values. )(
— Jeff Cox
THE PRAIRIE PROGRESSIVE • FEBRUARY 1999 • PAGE 2
Wellstone Out, Darling In
I ran for Governor of
Wen
alifoia in 1978, my
latform was clearly ahead of
its time, but today it doesn't sound
so far-fetched.
For example, I promised that if I
continued my political career and were
elected President, I would start the
Presidential Network (PTN.) As
President I would wear a small video
camera to record everything I said, saw
and heard. This camera would broad-
cast to every television set in America,
24 hours a day. Americans should have
the option of seeing what the President
sees. After all, we pay the bills.
On PTN, the President could inform
Americans of events on a daily basis,
and he could take the pulse of the
people by holding daily elections.
When a national consensus is required,
the President should not rely on polls
they are conducted today. We need
an honest, inclusive polling system
that reflects America's diversity. We
could vote with Total Democracy
Voting Cards, designed for television
sets, VCRs, gas pumps, and/or comput-
ers. American technology could make
this a reality.
With regards to campaign reform, I
support a system that would make
every political campaign in America
subject to the same scrutiny as our
current President has recently been
subjected. A campaign should be a
contract, and a politician should be
held accountable for any and all
statements made while seeking office.
What is true on the campaign trail
should be true after an election.
Here is why I am running for
President: Someone must convince
Congress to alter their attitude toward
education. A President need only study
our public schools to understand
America's major problem. An unedu-
ited population is not ideal for
.ontinuing democracy, and if we don't
beef up our schools, this nation is lost.
If America elects me as their next
President, I will focus all of the power
of the Presidency on solving the
education crisis in America. I will not
sign one budget until education is
on top.
We must train and hire far more
teachers, and we must build hundreds of
new schools. Wherever uncrowded
classrooms are needed, we must build
them. This revolution can occur in every
nook and cranny of this nation, and in
so doing we can rebuild America and
inspire the world —to say nothing of
restoring our children's faith in
their future.
"Where will the money come from?"
That is what politicians always say
when asked about education. Here is my
answer: America will retire as a world
military power. We will bring our troops
home, and their only job will be to
protect our nation from the threat of
foreign invasion, natural disaster, and to
meet America's contribution to the
United Nations. We will be one nation
among many, an equal partner in
world peace.
Following WWII, General Dwight
Eisenhower issued a severe warning
against our succumbing to the military -
industrial complex. Had we taken his
advice, America's dominant bureaucracy
today might be health and education
rather than the Pentagon. It is, however,
not yet too late to restore our priorities.
America should once again become
the great international experiment. We
are the testing ground to see if the
people of Earth can actually get along.
Everyone is represented here —every
race, religion, nationality, philosophy,
cult and ideology. Perhaps that's why
we feel compelled to tell the rest of the
world what to do, but we can no longer
afford this behavior.
If you support my basic concepts -
that we must make education bigger
and better than ever, and that we must
make it available to every child -help
send a mandate to Washington, DC.
Support my campaign for President of
the United States. Support PTN.
Support total democracy. Help find a
way for every American to be educated,
safe, and healthy.
In order to finance my campaign, I
am asking for contributions just like
every other candidate. And like every
other candidate, I hope to receive
matching federal funds. Unlike every
other candidate, however, I am promis-
ing to return my contributors money
along with half of mine. I will hire my
contributors to talk about my campaign.
Their salary will be one -and -a -half
times the amount of their contribution
(within the legal limits.) In other words,
if a contributor sends me $100, I will
hire that contributor at a salary of $150.
What politician has made you a
better offer? Supporting my campaign
is an investment. At last, a politician
who pays you to do nothing but talk. I
will be in Iowa in 1999, and I will hear
what you have to say then. In the
meantime, thanks for listening. )(
— Lowell Darling is the author of One
Hand Shaking, an account of his
California gubernatorial campaign,
in which he received 2% of the vote
against Jerry Brown.
Darling grew up in the Quad Cities
and is the only presidential candi-
date known to be a direct
descendant of Marcel Duchamp.
THE PRAwE PROGRESSIVE • FEBRUARY 1999 • PAGE 3
There's Something about Beloved
To ensure that this movie gets its
due from at least one source, I
hereby bestow the Prairie
Progressive Best Movie of the Year
Award on Beloved.
Three observations: First, Oprah
Winfrey —who is both the "mother of
the movie" (Demme) and Sethe, the
mother it the movie —apparently can
do about anything she sets her mind to.
Second, Jonathan Demme need take a
back seat to no other American direc-
tor. And third, the timing was bad for a
movie about slavery, when movies
about dumb white guys are reigning
supreme in Hollywood and the
Southern White Male has taken
over Washington.
After much hope and hype,
Beloved bombed at the box office. It
breaks your heart to read Winfrey's
journal about the making of the movie,
bursting with the joy of turning her 10-
year dream into reality and the belief
that this compelling story of her
ancestors would open the minds and
hearts of millions and help stop the
bleeding from our national shame.
Beloved was to be her Schindler's List.
How could it fail? Starring the
beloved Queen of Television (there is
no king), directed by an Oscar -winning
director, from a novel by the Nobel
laureate Toni Morrison. Try to top
that. Just as the novel never made it
easy on the reader, the movie refused
to play down to the viewer. It didn't
fail. Only at the box office.
Where it pays to be dumb. Not
only are dumb movies bringing in big
bucks, they are beginning to fool the
critics. Gene Siskel, the one with the
thin thumb, included There's Some-
thing About Mary in his list of ten best
movies of 1998. The only thing about
Mary is her knack for attracting stupid
white guys.
There are a lot of things about the
character Beloved, and most of them
defy explanation. She is the reincarna-
tion of the baby her mother killed to
save it from life as a slave. With this
act, Sethe went one step beyond the
horror of Sophie's choice. The strong
presence of the supernatural gave some
critics an opening to dismiss Beloved
as a ghost story, even a horror movie.
But the ghost and the horror in the
person of Beloved is the embodiment
of the tragedy of slavery, what
Morrison calls "the Misery," that
refuses to go away.
One critical mark of a good movie is
that you wake up thinking about it the
morning after. This one really haunts.
I played "most powerful scenes" with
two friends. Mine was easy: the
climactic killing -of -the -baby scene. I
can't imagine any other director doing
it better. Another chose Sethe seeing
Ohio, a free state, across the river for
the first time. The third was most
moved seeing the scars on the backs of
both Sethe and Paul D. during a love
scene, which was as gut wrenching a
sight as any whipping scene. Each of
these moments argues against the view
that the ghost element detracted from
the central theme of slavery. Every-
thing in the movie is about the physical
survivors of slavery struggling to
survive emotionally.
If the Academy is in a mood to
start making up for its history of
slighting Black filmmaking, Beloved has
a wealth of potential, deserving
nominations, beginning with the movie
itself. The remarkable young women of
Beloved—Thandie Newton (Beloved),
Kimberly Elise (Denver), and Lisa Gay
Hamilton (Young Sethe)—may have
already played the most important roles
of their lives.
No, America doesn't have the time
to deal with the slavery which stains its
history, nor with a movie about slavery.
It's too busy at the moment trying to
hold off a pack of Southerners out to
get a president whom, according to
Toni Morrison, many African -Ameri-
cans regard as their first black
President,"Blacker than any actual
black person who could ever be elected
in our children's lifetime." And not
even this president has dared issue a
formal apology for slavery. The only
part of slavery America wants to hear
about is Thomas Jefferson's DNA.
The top grosser during Beloved's
rapid exit from theaters was Waterboy,
a movie that, by any post -pubescent
standard, is as horrible as the subject
matter of Beloved is horrific. There is a
great irony in this. The title Waterboy
recalls the name of an actor, Stepin
Fetchit, who has come to symbolize the
degrading buffoonish roles that Blacks
were limited to in the early days of
Hollywood. Now it's the whites
playing the demeaning parts in
Hollywood's celebration of white male
stupidity, while an African -American
project like Beloved is too complex, too
serious, too intelligent for mainstream
moviegoers.
Beloved may not find its audience
until someday in the future, but film
history is sure to reward this noble
effort to face our past. )g
— Jae Retz
THE PRA/Rm PROGRESSIVE • FEBRUARY 1999 • PAGE 4
E•
CALEN
DAR
January 10,1989
Karen Kubby elected to
the Iowa City City
Council
January 30,1948
Gandhi assassinated
February26-27
Envisioning Sustainable
Worlds: Campus,
Curriculum, &
Community, a cultural
studies conference at
Drake University.
Speakers include Sandra
Sanchez, Linda
Appelgate, & Ed Fallon.
Free and open to the
public.
www.env.drake.edu/
sustain.html
March 23, 1989
The Exxon Valdez oil
tanker runs aground,
fouling 500 square miles
of Alaskan waters
March 26-27
Two-day Media Training
Seminar sponsored by
Women's Resource &
Action Center and
facilitated by the Spin
Project of San Francisco.
Trainer: Robert Bray,
former media director for
the Human Rights
Campaign Fund and the
National Gay/Lesbian
Task Force. Iowa
Memorial Union, Iowa
City, $50, 319-335-1486
March 27
Democratic Off -Year
Caucus, Johnson
County, 319-338-1997
March 28, 1979
Nuclear power plant at
Three Mile Island
malfunctions
THE PRAIRIE PROGRESSIVE has been published
quarterly since 1986. Editor for this issue: Dave Leshtz.
❑ $10 1-year subscription.
❑ $_ 1999 sustaining fund gift.
0 $8 1-year gift subscription
Your Name Gift Name
Your Address Gift Address
C)
O
A Special
Prairie Progressive
ThankYou
b to Joe Sharpnack and Loretta Popp for
creating the classic Beanie Baby fundraising
cartoon and the Prairie Dog Beanie Babies for
lifetime subscribers
b to the 74 readers who have contributed $1206
and 10,000 yen since Thanksgiving 1998
b to the comrades and relatives who have
stamped and labeled thousands of Prairie
Progressives with passion, gusto, and
bemusement
City, State Zip — City, State Zip
LPlease return to: The Prairie Progressive, P.O. Box 1945, Iowa City, IA 52244
G 4 � Te have no permanent
�! �/ friends, only permanent
issues. We are beholden to
no individual or party. Let us
turn up the heat until the
politicians see the light."
— Andy Stern,
President, SEIU
THE PRAmm PROGRESsrvE • FERRueRY 1999 • RAGE 5
Honor Roll,
Continued from Page I
the towel, saying that he would "no
longer dispatch morality patrols for
the state."
Randy Bezanson, Gil Cranberg, &
John Soloski began an in-depth study
of how ownership structures of
newspapers affect journalism. The UI
professors are examining how and why
newspapers are operating increasingly
for the sake of shareholders rather
than readers.
The student -led Gay/Straight
Alliance of Valley High and others in
the Des Moines area and Ames are
working against anti -gay bias in high
schools. Slurs and threats of violence
have failed to keep teenagers such as
Andy Cowan and Erin O'Brien from
providing supportive forums for
discussing sexual -orientation issues.
The Cedar Rapids Civil Rights
Commission voted 6-1 to recommend
adding "sexual orientation" to the
city's anti -discrimination ordinance.
Since that vote, the Cedar Rapids City
Council assured itself a spot on the
1999 Honor Roll by adopting the
recommendation,3-2. Voting yes were
Lee Clancy, Nancy Evans, and Dale
Todd
Having already astonished eastern
Iowa with its first -ever endorsement of
a Democrat for Governor, the Cedar
Rapids Gazette urged the City Council
to protect the rights of gays and
lesbians in the areas of employment,
education, credit, and housing.
Another Honor Roll hopeful for
1999: rookie State Senator Joe
Bolkcom, for resisting meth madness,
prison expansion, and tax breaks for
Iowans who least need them.
THE PRAIRIE PROGRESSIVE
Box 1945
Iowa City, IA 52244
"Justice does not help
those who slumber
but helps only those
who are vigilant:'
— Mahatma Gandhi
The Iowa City Citizens' Police
Review Board, formed in the wake of
the shooting of Eric Shaw, got off to a
slow start but showed courage by
taking seriously the growing number of
police stops for "driving while black."
Seven years ago Miya Rodolfo-
Sioson was a random victim of violence
on the University of Iowa campus.
Today she works for the Center for
Independent Living in Berkeley, where
she helped pass a city ordinance to
permanently fund emergency -assis-
tance services for people with severe
disabilities. Rodolfo's advice for
activists, with or without disabilities:
"There's tons of stuff you can still do.
Just focus on what you can do, and
don't worry about the stuff you
can't do." )°o
Prairie-E)q= —
CI
-
usnH
Fa.c-m.e,a
I(41) Tso►J
g03t�AcS��,